According to this ,already very much in the news ,Readers Digest Ranking New York City is the most polite city in the world, while Mumbai carries the distinction of being the least polite.
I want to move to NYC, LOL….. Mumbai ( I’ll take it as representative of India) fared the worst, well I won’t contest that, I mean after all that smiling at strangers and wishing them good morning , and thanking bus drivers, etc ,etc in NZ and to some extent in Alabama , if I did the same thing in India I’d get weird stares…may be ,just may be the folks who conducted the survey are prejudiced but it’s a dog eat dog world back home ,and people don’t try to hide it .
A simple hello in the West is just that, a greeting, sometimes you feel “Oh wow! That person keeps greeting me and saying hi, they must really like me”.. But the fact of the matter is, that it’s just force of habit, don’t expect the person who greeted you so nicely a to listen to the problems in your life.
Getting back to India , its tough , some times you get chided by peers just for saying please and thank you, and in the process lose any good manners you were brought up with , people think twice before giving up a hard earned bus seat to some one who probably needs it more, not everyone treats domestic help with respect , I don’t see many young nineteen year olds treating fifty five or sixty year old strangers with any particular respect , I like to think that under that core of brashness exists a national heart of gold , I bet it still exists , but it's getting harder and harder to find these days!!!
8 comments:
I am not trying to take sides here but its imporatnt to put things in perspective...
Incidently I read this article the same day you blogged about it.
http://epaper.timesofindia.com/Repository/ml.asp?Ref=VE9JTS8yMDA2LzA2LzI1I0FyMDEyMDI=&Mode=HTML&Locale=english-skin-custom
PS: I hope u dont mind a link on the comments
No i don't mind links on comments :))
I know the survey was biased in favor of western tradition, however for the sake of argument consider this article ….
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/1674607.cms
yep! this was in favor of the western practises, we are hardly used to say a mere *hi* or *howdy* to an unknown face, coz basically when we do it, most of the times we mean it...
in a lighter note, in any urban side of India, it will be sooo difficult to keep track of saying *good mornin* etc. to anyone n everyone..coz simply you will be tired in max. 15 mnts of repeating the same to a zillion faces!
Thats a good point , hi- hello system back home is probably wishful thinking:).. but just imagine how many barriers would be broken if we said hi to all the people we meet during day to day life in India.
hey there lady!
whats been happening? love the posts! u inspire me to get my groove on...soon...verrry soon...ill be back in verbal action!
-Nayana
..and i'm waiting eagerly for your next post Nayn :)!!!
i agree with that assessment by the Digest - though ofcourse they reached the right conclusion using somewhat dubious and not-so-well suited methodology - i cudnt care two hoots for the 'hi', 'hello' thing and its not the manners or the lack of it that bothers me.
If manners are cast off as an embellishment not a necessity, what about basic respect for an individual. being in time is a way to respect the other person and his time, keeping appointments is yet another and finally jumping the line.
My point is if you can't do good, atleast dont do evil - lack of a sense of fairplay and respect is absent and non-existent among us.
we easily blame the politician, the system and such. the problem is you...and well to take a lesson from what i said just right now, its me !!
if everyone says and believes that they themselves are the problem and takes measure to rectify, we will be okay.
"i am the problem". period. !
Post a Comment